7 Comments
User's avatar
Scott Wendler's avatar

Your response actually perfectly encapsulates many of my arguments made against your claims, which makes me laugh at how how overly hard you have to work at covering up and distorting the argument. Since you are correct that this format is not conducive for lengthy comments, I am going to focus on only one here.

Your continued use of 2nd Nephi 25:23 to claim that we (and the Book of Mormon) believe in a works based salvation. You purposefully avoided my claim of you taking that verse out of context, to then double down on removing it out of context, and then implying an alternative meaning to the phrase, "all you can do".

Yes, the phrase of "all you can do" does imply effort on our part. The problem with your claims are, you are implying that "all you can do" is talking about New Testament style works such as baptism. It is not, which is one point to emphasize as to the fact you are taking it out of context.

When you put the verse and the phrase "after all you can do" with the actual context of the verse, you see that it is talking about obeying the Law of Moses.

You see, in context, this verse is describing the beliefs of a Jewish culture who believed in the Savior and the atonement he would provide for all of us. Yet because they lived in a time that the law hadn't been fulfilled, knew they were still under commandment to obey the Law of Moses to the best of their ability. Thus they would be saved by grace (through the atonement of Jesus Christ) Yet knew that they still needed to obey the Law of Moses (after all they could do)

To emphasize how badly you must ignore the context of this verse to reach your conclusion, why don't you include the verses after verse 23? If your interpretation is valid, the next verses would no doubt back up your claim, right? Lets read the verses together and see if they imply what you are claiming they imply?

23 For we labor diligently to write, to persuade our children, and also our brethren, to believe in Christ, and to be reconciled to God; for we know that it is by grace that we are saved, after all we can do.

24 And, notwithstanding we believe in Christ, we keep the law of Moses, and look forward with steadfastness unto Christ, until the law shall be fulfilled.

25 For, for this end was the law given; wherefore the law hath become dead unto us, and we are made alive in Christ because of our faith; yet we keep the law because of the commandments.

26 And we talk of Christ, we rejoice in Christ, we preach of Christ, we prophesy of Christ, and we write according to our prophecies, that our children may know to what source they may look for a remission of their sins.

27 Wherefore, we speak concerning the law that our children may know the deadness of the law; and they, by knowing the deadness of the law, may look forward unto that life which is in Christ, and know for what end the law was given. And after the law is fulfilled in Christ, that they need not harden their hearts against him when the law ought to be done away.

If you are going to imply any "New Testament" style implications from this verse, I could argue the New Testament commands us to do many things, Yet salvation is only found through belief in Jesus Christ. Those things we are commanded to do don't actually save us. Your continued use of taking this verse out of context doesn't back up the claims you are giving it. Hence why I find your continued use of thisargument about this verse particularly galling.

I am open to addressing more of your claims here, as your Gish-Gallop of arguments here all share a certain level of deception on your case to make.

Rob Alsobrook's avatar

Scott,

Your charge of “Gish-Gallop” and “deception” is noted, but let’s stay with the one text you insist I misread (2 Nephi 25:23) and let the whole counsel of Scripture judge who is handling it faithfully.

1. The Plain Grammar of 2 Nephi 25:23

“…it is by grace that we are saved, after all we can do.”

Subject: “we” (the speakers—Nephi’s people).

Verb: “are saved” (passive—salvation is received).

Prepositional phrase: “after all we can do” (temporal sequence: grace follows maximal human effort).

No amount of surrounding context can erase the sequence: effort → grace. That is the opposite of Ephesians 2:8-9:

“For by grace you have been saved through faith… not a result of works (ouk ex ergōn), so that no one may boast.”

Paul’s Greek is absolute: salvation is never “a result of works”—not Mosaic, not New Covenant, not any. The same Paul who wrote Ephesians also wrote Galatians 2:21:

“I do not nullify the grace of God, for if righteousness comes through the Law, then Christ died needlessly.”

2. Your “Context” Argument Collapses Under Its Own Weight

You insist “all we can do” = only keeping the Law of Moses pre-Christ. Fine, let’s test that against your own scripture :

•2 Nephi 25:24–25 says, “we keep the law of Moses… yet we keep the law because of the commandments.”

Implication: Law-keeping is commanded obedience—i.e., works.

•Mosiah 13:28 (still in Book of Mormon) says, “if it were not for the atonement… salvation would come by the law of Moses.”

Implication: Explicitly, salvation by works (law-keeping) apart from atonement.

•Official LDS Manual (Preach My Gospel, Ch. 3) says, “Obedience to the laws and ordinances of the gospel is necessary for salvation.”

Implication: Post-Christ, obedience (baptism, temple, etc.) is still required.

So even if 2 Nephi 25:23 only meant Mosaic obedience (It doesn’t. See v. 30: “we keep the performances… until the law is fulfilled”), your own canon extends the principle into the New Covenant era.

You can’t have it both ways:

Claim “all we can do” = only obsolete law → then why does modern LDS soteriology require ongoing ordinances?

Admit it includes New Covenant works → then you openly contradict Ephesians 2:8–9.

3. The Biblical Antidote: Grace Is Prevenient, Not Subsequent

Romans 5:8 – “While we were still sinners, Christ died for us.”

Titus 3:5 – “He saved us, not because of righteous things we had done, but because of His mercy.”

John 6:44 – “No one can come to Me unless the Father… draws him.”

Grace precedes. Effort follows.

Your (LDS) system: Effort → Grace. The Bible calls this “another gospel” of a different kind altogether (Gal 1:8-9).

4. The Real Out-of-Context Move

You say I “imply New Testament style works” into 2 Nephi. But you quote Paul (1 Cor 15:3–4) as if the Book of Mormon agrees—while your own prophets add temple sealings, tithing, and eternal marriage as non-negotiable for exaltation. That’s the actual eisegesis, not exegesis.

You accuse me of “distortion.” I simply read your text in its plain sense, then tested it against Paul’s. The verdict is not mine, it is Scripture’s:

Galatians 5:4 – “You who are trying to be justified by law have been alienated from Christ; you have fallen away from grace.”

Scott, the gospel is not a ladder. It is a cross. Christ’s work is finished (John 19:30). No “after all we can do.” Just faith in the One who did it all.

I’m praying you’ll rest there.

Grace alone, Rob Alsobrook

Scott Wendler's avatar

I give you serious props on your ability to misrepresent what the Book of Mormon says, as your misrepresentation of Mosiah 13:28 is a masterclass. The only way it says " If not for the atonement... salvation comes through the law of Moses", is when you misquote it and remove the rest of the actual verse. For example, I will capitalize the words you used to make up your "quote" from Mosiah 13:28.

28 And moreover, I say unto you, that SALVATION doth not come by the law alone; and WERE IT NOT FOR THE THE ATONEMENT, which God himself shall make for the sins and iniquities of his people, that they must unavoidably perish, notwithstanding THE LAW OF MOSES.

So yes it does say what you claim, when you randomly grab words to rearrange as you desire. Instead you see that if they only believed in the Law of Moses only, they would not be saved, which is the exact opposite of your claim that this verse makes. (so I will repeat my point that I have to keep making with you, context actually matters!)

So you pulled a quote from Preach my Gospel without context. Congratulations! I am going to show you why this is so dangerous:

Mark 16:16

16 He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved; but he that believeth not shall be damned.

1st Peter 3:21

21 The like figure whereunto even baptism doth also now save us (not the putting away of the filth of the flesh, but the answer of a good conscience toward God,) by the resurrection of Jesus Christ:

These verses back up that Baptism is salvific. No other context or other verses surrounding these verses are necessary to understanding the very plain understanding of these verses, correct? If your answer is "No", then why are you allowed to have a double standard when the plain text of verses don't back up what you want them to say and you demand further context to understand these verses? Yet when I do that with the Book of Mormon, you claim I am not handling things "faithfully" as you state in your opening paragraph.

Since you have a demonstrable habit of misrepresenting what things say (see your Mosiah "quotation" for example) I simply don't have faith in you accurately portraying anything, so give me the fuller context form that quote mine you did from Preach my Gospel.

What both ways are you talking about? 2nd Nephi 25:23 clearly is representing "all you can do" as obeying the Law of Moses.

Regarding the Church's insistence in "New Testament" style works is simply an extension of what we read and understand about Faith in the Bible. The verses you quoted regarding faith only distract from this, as of course Grace is fully available for us before we use it, as it was fully provided for everyone when Jesus Christ uttered, "It is finished". These verses you mentioned only touch on one aspect of faith, therefore if you are not willing to include other verses to fully include the fuller meaning of Faith, it appears manipulative and deceptive. Plus your misrepresentation of our belief in effort before grace grossly misrepresents your position as well.

While Faith truly is a gift, do we do nothing to recognize it or strengthen it? Are we able to fully receive the grace of God if we don't pray and ask God for forgiveness? If we never pray and ask for forgiveness, do we still fully have access to all of God's Grace? Does this mean that People can be saved without knowing it? The implications in your claim are staggering. While yes, The grace of God is so perfect and complete that it can save everyone, the fact of the matter is, not everyone will be saved.

Faith, according to the Bible, is only complete with physical action to accompany it.

See James 2:17-23 and Eph 2:8-10. (Again, see my argument regarding plain text reading of these verses, as opposed to you wanting to add any "context" to them.)

Yes, Modern day prophets do add works to Exaltation, seeing how they are required. Yet others can receive salvation, (Remember salvation being the escape of physical death and the gift of not experiencing the eternal consequences of sin) through Faith on the Lord Jesus Christ.

And to quote a scripture to end, I am glad you are happy in quoting Paul to claim the truth of your argument, However, I am not of Paul, or Apollos, or Cephas, I am of Jesus Christ. (1 Cor 1:12-14)

I hope you have a great day.

Rob Alsobrook's avatar

Scott, props for the spin: you’re mixing verses like a 90s techno DJ on Red Bull. Let’s drop the act and stick to facts.

1. Mosiah 13:28: I paraphrased the counterfactual perfectly: without atonement, even law-keepers perish. Your “full quote” proves it. No salvation by works, period. You just proved my point while yelling “misquote.”

2. Preach My Gospel, p. 62: “Obedience to the laws and ordinances of the gospel is necessary for salvation.” Verbatim. No mining. Your demand for “fuller context”? That is the context. Own it.

3. Mark 16:16: The second half says unbelief damns, not unbaptized. Thief on the cross: zero water, full paradise. Try again.

4. 1 Peter 3:21 (among a myriad of other cf refutes your claim): Baptism saves “not the removal of dirt” but the appeal of faith. Peter rejects LDS water-works magic.

5. James 2 + Eph 2: Saved by faith (v.8-9), for works (v.10). Fruit, not root. You’re eating the peel and calling it the apple.

6. “It is finished” = done. Not “start obeying harder.” Grace isn’t a vending machine.

7. 2 Nephi 25:23: “After all we can do” = effort first. Paul: “Not of works” (Eph 2:9). Pick a lane.

You say “I’m of Christ.” Paul says another Jesus = accursed (Gal 1:8). The LDS Jesus is Lucifer’s brother. The real One is God incarnate.

The gospel isn’t a staircase. It’s a cross. Rest there, Scott.

Want to look deeper at the text (Biblical references) further in Greek and context? It’s undeniable. LDS theology and gospel message is incompatible with the Bible and Jesus’s gospel.

No spin. Just Scripture.

Grace alone,
Rob

Rob Alsobrook's avatar

Regarding the Biblical relationship to baptism, I’ve written on this before should you care to see how Scripture approaches it comprehensively:

https://open.substack.com/pub/docilitas/p/does-baptism-save?r=59shrw&utm_medium=ios

Scott Wendler's avatar

LOL "paraphrasing" you took the exact opposite of what Mosiah 13 said in in your "paraphrasing". You might have mistyped it, but that is as generous as I am willing to be. Your "paraphrase" literally states the Law of Moses could save, which that verse specifically says it can't.

It is apparent that you don't know what the word context means, so I will provide the google definition below to help you.

- the circumstances that form the setting for an event, statement, or idea, and in terms of which it can be fully understood and assessed.

- the parts of something written or spoken that immediately precede and follow a word or passage and clarify its meaning.

Simply restating something is the exact opposite of context. Why don't you be honest and admit you don't want to apply context, because in so doing shows how badly you are trying to frame our theology?

So wait, you are claiming paradise and Heaven are the same place? So when Jesu says to the thief on the cross that he will be with him that day in paradise, yet when he was resurrected and told Mary that he had not yet ascended to the Father, (John 20:17) does this mean that God doesn't exist in heaven? Your overly simple justification also ignores the fact that it explicitly says baptism. while yes unbelief damns, (duh) yet this verse specifically says baptism. I believe I will take your words for this situation, "own it".

Like with Mark where you try to ignore the word baptism to justify an alternative meaning that conveniently leaves out baptism being salvific, why else would you be baptized? Of course it is to faith, yet that doesn't dispel the use of baptism here, unless you can point to places in the Bible where they are baptizing unbelievers?

James 2 and Eph 2, wait, the peel is not a part of the apple? Who knew.

Of course grace isn't a vending machine, yet there are going to be those who don't access it.

To be fair, Paul would say the same thing about your Trinitarian Jesus, a Jesus that he never once taught. And your appeal to Gal 1:8 just doesn't work. The Book of Mormon teaches of the same Jesus who will save all who have faith on his name. (and yes, the Book of Mormon teaches of this same Incarnate Jesus as well, despite your claims)

If your claims about the Greek and context are so sound, then why are there so many different interpretations of these texts. If they are as resolute as you claim, why doesn't every Mainstream Christian church teach the exact same thing? Yet you have all different denominations who all interpret various passages differently, all with Scholars of Greek telling them what the verses mean.

I am glad you have faith in your interpretations, but I have the truth from God himself, not through the wisdom of man. Despite your claims, I know who Jesus is, and I have felt his grace and peace throughout my life.