A friend passed along alarming content for my impressions from a Facebook post making the rounds—the kind that sets off a quiet alarm in any Bible-loving brain:
'Wait… is that exegesis or just really passionate guesswork?'.
It quoted Andrew DeCort, a theologian known for his emphasis on neighbor-love and social ethics, and referenced an article from the Junia Project by Harriet Reed Congdon, a writer engaging with gender and power dynamics in Scripture.
The post reads:
“When Israel escaped from the genocidal injustice of Egyptian slavery, Moses blessed his people and criminalized compassion. He said, ‘You will be more blessed than any other people… You must destroy all the peoples the Lord your God gives over to you. Do not look on them with compassion’ (Deuteronomy 7:14-16).
Sadly, the blessed ache for justice ended up vomiting up pain and justifying genocide. The eyes of compassion were told to look away from others in pain. No wonder Jesus’ practice of compassion gave him such a notorious reputation.
One day, a Canaanite woman approached Jesus and pleaded with him, ‘Have compassion on me!’ Her child was sick, and she was desperate for help (Matthew 15:22). But she was a Canaanite. And she was asking for the exact thing that Moses explicitly said Canaanites should never be given: compassion. In fact, Moses said that she and her child should be killed—not cured!
But Jesus was divergent.
After this woman took the risk of asking for his compassion, Jesus surrendered Moses’ supremacist mindset. He chose mercy. He not only refused to follow Moses’ genocidal order, he defiantly reversed it. Jesus healed her suffering child. But then he went further. He praised this othered woman—a Canaanite!—for her faith (Matthew 15:28).
Let us be frank. This passage is a tangle of emotive rhetoric and theological confusion. It is precisely the sort of sentimentally driven reinterpretation of Scripture that C.S. Lewis warned against when he observed the modern tendency to judge the past through the lens of present-day moral instincts rather than truth.
As a Christian and student of Scripture, I offer this response not in the spirit of outrage but of urgent clarity. Bad theology leads to bad anthropology and, inevitably, to a diluted Christ.
Misrepresenting Moses: Justice, Not Genocide
To begin with, the claim that Moses "criminalized compassion" or espoused a "supremacist mindset" is both historically and theologically reckless. The Deuteronomic commands to destroy the Canaanite nations were not acts of imperialism or racial supremacy, but of divine judgment.
Leviticus 18 outlines the abominable practices of these nations: child sacrifice, sexual perversion, and idolatry. God’s command to Israel was a judicial act rooted in holiness, not nationalism (Deut. 9:4-6).
Deuteronomy 9:4-6 says repeatedly, ... “it is on account of the wickedness of these nations that the Lord is going to drive them out before you.” (emphasis added)
To ignore the context and moral gravity of Canaanite culture is to commit a gross misdiagnosis of moral categories. This is not Moses committing genocide. It is God administering long-awaited judgment through His covenant people after centuries of forbearance (Genesis 15:16).
Did Jesus Reverse Moses? No—He Fulfilled Him
The central claim that Jesus "surrendered Moses’ supremacist mindset" is not only unfounded, it flirts with heresy. In Matthew 5:17, Jesus says clearly,
"Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them."
The Canaanite woman’s encounter with Jesus is not an act of Jesus repenting of the Torah. Rather, it is a powerful revelation that God's mercy extends beyond ethnic Israel to the nations. His initial silence and measured response were intentional, meant to draw out the woman’s persistent, humble faith for the benefit of the disciples, who were still entangled in their own ethnocentric assumptions.
Jesus does not change His mind. He tests, reveals, and commends. "O woman, great is your faith!" (Matt. 15:28). Far from being rebuked by her, He lifts her up as a model of faith.
Faith, Not Rebuke, Defines the Encounter
The notion that the woman "challenged" Jesus or "corrected" His mission misunderstands the dynamic entirely. Her appeal is not a rebuke but a beautifully humble acknowledgment of unworthiness:
"Even the dogs eat the crumbs that fall from their master's table" (Matt. 15:27).
She accepts her place outside the covenant and yet throws herself on His mercy. And it is precisely that posture that Christ praises. If Jesus needed correcting, He’s not the Christ—just a clever rabbi with a blind spot. And that’s not a minor misstep; it’s a blasphemous proposition.
If you can correct your Savior, He is no longer your Savior because He can’t be anyone’s Savior.
Misusing Hosea: Mercy and Sacrifice
Quoting Hosea 6:6 out of context to suggest God desires compassion instead of sacrifice rather than more than sacrifice is another hermeneutical misstep. Hosea critiques heartless ritualism, not moral judgment. The same God who says "I desire mercy" also says, "I will punish them for their sins" (Hosea 8:13).
Jesus Himself, when quoting Hosea in Matthew 9:13, does so to critique the self-righteousness of the Pharisees, not the moral law.
It is not mercy over justice but mercy within justice.
The Church's Task Is Not Therapeutic Dialogue, But Proclamation
Finally, to suggest that Jesus created space for "give-and-take" dialogue where He was open to being corrected in His mission reduces Him to a conflicted moral teacher rather than the incarnate Logos. The church is not called to foster endless therapeutic dialogue, but to declare the truth revealed in Christ with humility and courage.
We do not honor Christ or the Scriptures by treating them as clay to be molded by our modern interests, cultural conditions and/or anxieties.
Conclusion: The Danger of Sentimental Theology
This entire re-reading of Moses and Jesus reflects a deep problem: theology shaped by emotion and social theory rather than exegesis and revelation.
When we read the Bible primarily to affirm modern values rather than challenge them, we lose both its authority but rather attempt to impose our authority onto it, as if that has ever worked out well.
To be compassionate, yes. But to be compassionate on God's terms, rooted in truth, holiness, and the full counsel of Scripture. Anything less is not Christlike love, it is just well-meaning rebellion dressed in the language of justice.
Let the church beware.
Don’t keep it to yourself. Like it. Share it. Comment. Engage. Not for clicks, but for Kingdom solidarity that challenges cultural compromise and points back to the unshakable Word of God.
🌱 This mission doesn’t run on good intentions alone (though we have plenty).
🙌 It runs on prayer, provision, and people like you.
🤝 Every gift you give goes directly to gospel work: evangelism, discipleship, biblical teaching, and loving people well in places where the Church is barely visible — or completely absent.
❤️ So, if you've ever wanted to be part of something eternal without moving to the other side of the world or giving up coffee, here's your chance.
💡 Join us in the Great Commission — because planting, watering, and harvesting the Word of God takes all kinds of hands! (yours included)




