Let’s be honest: if Joseph Smith really saw God the Father in full glory, as he claimed in his First Vision, we have two options.
Either Joseph Smith was not a man, or the Bible is not true.
There’s not a lot of interpretive wiggle room between those two statements.
Over the past several months, I’ve had the privilege (and an exercise in patience and pattern recognition) of engaging in extended online dialogue with several members of the LDS (Mormon) church. To their credit, they have been passionate, persistent, and sincerely convinced that their view is rooted in Scripture.
But passion is not exegesis, and sincerity is not truth.
What follows is a breakdown of the seven most common interpretive missteps I’ve encountered from Latter-day Saints in defense of Joseph Smith’s claim to have seen God the Father in bodily glory. I hope to show not only why these arguments fail exegetically but also why they reveal a fundamentally different approach to Scripture and the gospel itself.
1. Equating “Seeing God” with Seeing God’s Essence
Quote: "As Jacob, Abraham, and Moses saw God so too did Joseph."
Here’s the issue: the Bible explicitly says that no one can see God (the Father) in His unmediated glory and live (Exodus 33:20; 1 Timothy 6:16; John 1:18). Every time someone "sees" God in the Bible, it is either through a vision (like Isaiah 6 or Acts 7) or a theophany (a visible manifestation). These are mediated, symbolic, or partial disclosures—never a direct, unhindered sight of God's essence. Joseph Smith claimed something categorically different.
2. Flattening Idioms into Literal Statements
Quote: "Moses spoke to God face to face, as one man speaks to another!!!"
Indeed, Exodus 33:11 uses the phrase "face to face" (Hebrew,פָּנִים אֶל־פָּנִים: panim el panim), but we must read the whole chapter. Just nine verses later, God says, "You cannot see my face, for man shall not see me and live" (v.20). So what gives? The answer lies in genre and idiom. "Face to face" is a Hebrew expression for relational intimacy and clarity, not retinal exposure to divine photons. Only by approaching Scripture exegetically and considering how language functioned in its original context can we discern the difference between what is literal and what is idiomatic.
This is reinforced in Numbers 12:6–8, where God contrasts His indirect communication with other prophets to His uniquely clear and direct relationship with Moses—“not in dark sayings,” but “mouth to mouth” (Hebrew: פֶּה אֶל־פֶּה, peh el peh)—again emphasizing intimacy, not physical sight.
3. Confusing "Glory" with Essence
Quote: "Moses saw God’s glory and goodness—so it must have been His full presence."
Not quite. When Moses asks to see God's glory (Exodus 33:18), God says He will let His goodness pass by but will hide Moses in a cleft of rock and cover him with His hand. The Hebrew term for “glory” (כָּבוֹד, kavod) and the Greek word used throughout the New Testament (δόξα, doxa) often refer to the radiance or majesty associated with God's presence—not God's essence. No one gets the full download and survives.
4. Treating the Imago Dei as Anatomical
Quote: "We’re made in God’s image, and Adam had a son in his image, so God must have a body!"
This argument commits a classic category error. Genesis 1:26–27 says we're made in God's image (צֶלֶם, tselem) and likeness (דְּמוּת, demut), but in the context of the Ancient Near East, these terms refer to our function as God's representatives—our moral, rational, and spiritual capacities. God is spirit (John 4:24), not an exalted human with celestial facial hair and heavenly real estate, respectfully.
5. Subjectivizing Revelation
Quote: "We don’t rely on man’s wisdom but the revelation of the Holy Ghost."
Sounds spiritual. The problem? Scripture repeatedly warns against revelations that contradict the gospel (Galatians 1:8-9) or claim private authority over public truth (2 Peter 1:20-21). The Holy Spirit inspired Scripture. He doesn't override it.
The claim that Joseph's vision should be accepted despite contradicting the Bible is not an appeal to faith—it's a theological jailbreak.
6. Prooftexting Instead of Harmonizing
Quote: "All I need is one verse that says God was seen!"
This isn’t how theology works. We don’t build doctrines on one verse, especially when other verses directly qualify it. Narrative must be interpreted through doctrine, not the reverse. Exodus 33:20 and 1 Timothy 6:16 interpret the "sightings" of God as partial, not total. Otherwise, Scripture contradicts itself. And as Jesus said, "The Scripture cannot be broken" (John 10:35).
7. Confusing the Persons of the Trinity
Quote: "Jesus has a body. He’s God. So the Father must have a body too!"
This collapses Trinitarian theology into modalism or worse. Yes, Jesus is fully God and fully man. But the Father is not the Son. Only the Son took on flesh (John 1:14); the Father remains invisible (John 1:18), unapproachable (1 Tim. 6:16), and spirit (John 4:24). Confusing their roles and natures creates a doctrinal mess the Nicene Creed already cleaned up 1700 years ago.
Lastly: Not Just a Different Interpretation but a Different Theology
At the end of the day, the issue isn't just how one reads a verse here or there. It’s about the framework: is Scripture interpreted as a coherent, self-revealing whole, or overridden by post-biblical visions and private teenage prophets? Joseph Smith claimed to see God in a way the Bible says is impossible.
Either Scripture is wrong, or he is.
Biblical Christianity affirms that God is holy, spirit, and infinitely beyond human perception—except where He has chosen to reveal Himself: in the Word, through the prophets, and ultimately in Jesus Christ, the image of the invisible God (Colossians 1:15).
That’s not my interpretation. That’s the Bible.
Soli Deo Gloria.
A Final Word to My LDS Friends
If you've made it this far, thank you. I don’t take your time—or your convictions—lightly.
My aim in writing this isn't to win an argument or to mock your faith, but to appeal to your conscience and your commitment to truth. My deepest concern is that what you’ve been taught about God, Scripture, and salvation is built on interpretations that cannot stand under the weight of careful, biblical exegesis.
I urge you: test every spirit. Don’t just follow tradition or emotion—let the Word of God be your foundation. If what Joseph Smith claimed is true, it will stand up to the full scrutiny of Scripture. But if it isn’t, then eternity is too high a price to pay for misplaced trust.
Grace and truth are not enemies. My hope is that you’ll search the Scriptures afresh—not through the lens of post-biblical revelations, but through the inspired, sufficient Word of God.
In Christ’s love,
Rob Alsobrook
🙏 Help Keep This Work Going
If this article helped clarify your understanding of Scripture — or helped you share truth with someone in the LDS church — consider sharing it.
You can also support this publication by subscribing, commenting, or becoming a paid supporter to help keep content like this going.
This mission doesn’t run on good intentions alone (though we have plenty).
It runs on prayer, provision, and people like you.
Every gift you give goes directly to gospel work: evangelism, discipleship, biblical teaching, and loving people well in places where the Church is barely visible — or completely absent.
So, if you've ever wanted to be part of something eternal without moving to the other side of the world or giving up coffee, here's your chance.
💡 Join us in the Great Commission — because planting, watering, and harvesting the Word of God takes all kinds of hands.



